Monday, 23 April 2007

Response from Peter Sluglett on"Sectarianism: Our Miserable Reality"

Dear All,

Please find below the response I had received from Mr. Sluglett about my latest post titled "Sectarianism, our miserable reality". Prof Peter Sluglett is the British historian who was debating this sensitive subject with a group of Iraqi "Academics" on other blogsite.

for details about Prof. Peter Sluglett, please click below:

http://www.hum.utah.edu/display.php?module=facultyDetails&personId=637&orgId=302

Mr. sluglett's response ( in dark blue and bold letters):

(Recently I have noticed that there is a growing trend by many academics, Arabs as well as Iraqis, journalists and even bloggers interested in Iraqi political history, to paint a rosy picture of Iraq prior to the American invasion in 2003. It was a very good tactic, as on one hand, they denounce the whole political process endorsed by the Americans in Iraq and criticises the failure of subsequent Iraqi governments (which is right as things are moving from bad to worse in Iraq now), But on the other hand, these strategies work intentionally to “polish” Saddam and the Ba’ath dictatorship. In addition and through a process of “desensitization”, these people deny, or at least, try to lessen the impact of Saddam’s regime atrocities by comparing them to what is happening now.
I am well aware of the dangers of that and I don’t think I can be accused of doing so.
For example, when Abdul-Bari Attwan of Al-Quds Al-Arabi newspaper, was asked in an interview about the mass graves and Saddam’s Mukhabarat torture chambers, he purposefully answered the question by a comparison with what the Americans did in Abu Ghraib prison. These attempts are seriously dangerous as conclude that Iraqis do not deserve a decent, peaceful and prosperous life. Furthermore, it states that we always must be ruled by dictators otherwise we will end up with what we currently have under the American occupation. This is a variant of the strong man theory beloved by, among others, the absurd Majid Khadduri This issue is very complicated and has many aspects that needs to be addressed and discussed thoroughly but I am trying to highlight one fundamental problem that dominated the modern Iraq History: Sectarianism. If you regularly follow popular Iraqi blogs (some are listed on my blog site) and the way they handle the “Sectarianism” issue in Iraqi society, you can admit that most of them try to persuade us that Sectarianism was not known to Iraqis until the Americans invaded Iraq. Ma kan farq baynana etc So it was a post 2003 phenomenon. Obviously nonsense.
Moreover, they insist that previous regimes that ruled Iraq from 1921 to 2003 was not sectarian-built and the Shia of Iraq in particular, were well represented in all parts of the government. Neither of these two things is correct, but it is much more nuanced.
Look at the following excerpts: “The reality is, back then, the British did not use the divide and rule among the Moslem population so you never new who was a Shia and who was a Sunni” Nonsense again “Iraqis at the time and later never considered themselves as Sunni or Shia but as Muslims. That was the reality” Also rubbish “We, Iraqis, do not identify ourselves as Sunnis and Shias, not even as Moslems or Christians, not before the occupation anyway. When asked about our identity we would say: Iraqis. The 1970 Iraqi Constitution, which is still valid, as we do not recognize a constitution written by the occupier, states that Iraq consists of two main ethnic groups: Arabs and Kurds, in addition to Turkmen and other groups. We do not consider a sect or a religion is an identity” Again this is an invention “The Iraqi non-sectarian approach to Iran and Da'wa party and other similar parties was obvious from the fact that most of the Iraqi troops which fought Iran during the 8 years war, were Shias defending "not their faith" but their own country against Iran” There is a certain amount of truth in this “The intifada which took part in the south during the crisis of the Kuwait war and after the withdrawal of the Iraqi army, while the state was at its weakest, was run by the Iranian guards and militias, the same which are conducting now the crimes of mass kidnapping, torturing, and killing.” This reflects an anti-Iranian bias which both does and does not have substance. “All what we hear now is how the Shiites were excluded from the government jobs and the high ranks in the baath party and the Iraqi cabinets under the rule of baath party. We don’t hear about how the Sunnis suffered too, and the Turkumans and the Kurds and everyone”. Again, sentence 1 is fairly accurate and sentence 2 we tried to address in Iraq since 1958 .. The above were extracts from correspondences by Iraqi academics (and one from another popular Iraqi blog) debating the issue of sectarianism with a British historian dealing specifically with modern Iraqi history since the 70s. It is obvious that they deny any sectarian elements in our history especially when it comes to the sensitive issue of Shia and Sunnis. The point is, not to deny sectarianism, but to look and see how it actually functioned. Iraq 1920-6t3 for instance wasn’t Northern Ireland where the largest political fact was the Catholic/Protestant split. Now, let’s look at facts and stop hiding things under the carpet. We have to admit that sectarianism is deeply embedded in our society since the Othoman-Safavid wars era. It was intensified with the creation of modern Iraq in 1921 and it was the ONLY stable Iraqi political phenomenon that successive regimes, including the current government (except Abdul Kareem Qassim’s’ regime) agreed upon. BUT it was a political sectarianism manipulated by the state against its citizens and not obviously apparent (although present) on grass root levels. Again even this seems a bit strong because for most of the time it was a government run by Sunnis rather than a Sunni government.
Covering the aspects of this issue from 1921 until now needs books to be written rather than a blog. Exactly; it also benefits from comparison with Bosnia, Lebanon etc.)

36 comments:

gilgamesh X / exile - iraqi said...

Hello Shako Mako,

I enjoyed reading your debate but would you be so kind to give us the link about the discussions with other Iraqi bloggers / historians ?

Thanks and great post, تحياتي

網頁設計 said...

hooray, your writings on theater and writing much missed!

網站設計 said...

hooray, your writings on theater and writing much missed!

Anonymous said...

If you are going for finest contents like me, simply visit
this web page all the time because it presents quality contents, thanks

Here is my weblog: bankruptcy laws in florida

Anonymous said...

I do not know if it's just me or if everyone else experiencing issues
with your blog. It looks like some of the text within your content
are running off the screen. Can someone else please comment and let me
know if this is happening to them too? This might be a problem with my internet browser because I've had this happen previously.

Thanks

My website: melaleuca

Anonymous said...

While dealing with such postings, quality content do matter for
your forums. What I mean here is that your particular content has to appeal for the reader for reasons unknown or the other.


link; http://tr.im,

Anonymous said...

Wow, marvelous blog layout! How long have you been blogging for?
you make blogging look easy. The overall look of your site is wonderful, let alone the content!


Feel free to surf to my homepage; casinoproffen.com

Anonymous said...

Hey! I know this is kind of off topic but I was wondering which blog platform are you using for this website?

I'm getting tired of Wordpress because I've had problems with hackers and I'm looking at
alternatives for another platform. I would be great if you could point me in the direction of a good platform.


Here is my web blog ... most effective wrinkle cream [khonrakban-rayong.com]

Anonymous said...

*They assist establish functional technique аnd alѕo involve inntellectual excitement.
" The lady''s posted over 15 books as of yet, the woman newest, Covert Write about-Up was launched in Dec 2009 just by Harlequin - Really like Encouraged Suspense. It's a great deal thrilling learning the needs of the opposite participants along with experiencing the way you get ranking versus other spider solitaire solitaire gamers.

Also visit my weblog - free solitaire game downloads

Anonymous said...

Sometimes just performing nothing will bring needed clarity.
Remember, psychic readings take time and can depart you sensation susceptible and emotional.

But then, alongside with the good, there are the bad.


my web blog: certified psychics ()

Anonymous said...

Does your website have a contact page? I'm having a tough time
locating it but, I'd like to shoot you an e-mail.
I've got some ideas for your blog you might be interested in hearing.
Either way, great website and I look forward to seeing it grow over time.


My web-site - jetpack joyride hack android download

Anonymous said...

Heƴ I know this is offf topіc but I was wondering іf you knew
ߋf any widgets I could add to my blog that automatically tweet my newest twitter
updates. I've Ьeen looking for a plug-in like this for quite some time and was hoping maybe you
would have some experience with something like this. Pleasе let me қƄow if you гun into
anythіng. I truly enjoy reading your bloց ɑand I look forward
to your neա updates.

Also visit my weeb blog; Massive Hotel Reserѵations []

Anonymous said...

Make guaranteed to search for significantly lower rates: Low credit card processing costs can be a merchant's
top priority. The challenge: pay promptly---but in the last possible moment---while avoiding late payment.

Increases productivity by providing on-some time to
accurate financial repots from the company for review and doing future planning.


my webpage :: online payroll services

Anonymous said...

Hey very interesting blog!

My website - seo basics

Anonymous said...

Great blog here! Also your web site loads up fast! What host are you using?
Can I get your affiliate link to your host? I wish my web site loaded
up as fast as yours lol

Look at my site ... www

Anonymous said...

I just wanted to mention I love your blog site concept, it's fantastic.

Well-done!

My web site vg e juice; ,

Anonymous said...

If you wish for to grow your know-how just keep visiting
this site and be updated with the most up-to-date information posted here.


Here is my homepage; insulation construction

Anonymous said...

Becauѕe of his attitսde of superiority, your eх bߋyfriend is
ready to play his game with yoս and inflate his ego
some more. Relаtionships don't work on estimatіons and logic". The key to winning back your ex is to play the whole thing cool.

Look into my blog; Make ʜim Desire
You Free Downloaԁ

Anonymous said...

Hi there to every one, the contents existing at
this web page are truly awesome for people knowledge,
well, keep up the nice work fellows.

Also visit my web site gra strategiczna

Anonymous said...

It iss in reality a nice and helpful piece of info. I'm satisfied that youu just shared this
useful info with us. Please keep us informed like this. Thank you for
sharing.

my website: throne rush hack ios

Anonymous said...

Know that you are not only growing great
organic plants and saving money for yourself, but you are also contributing to the well-being of the future.
The free plan does not give you full access to the database or all
its features, but is useful for the home gardener. There are several videos which for teaching the gardener how to look after various types of plants.


Review my page: website []

Anonymous said...

Thanks for the auspicious writeup. It in reality was once a enjoyment account it.
Look advanced to far delivered agreeable from you! By the way, how can we keep up
a correspondence?

Here is my blog; เกมส์ทายใจ

Anonymous said...

• Wrinkles on the forehead and around the eyes: Hydroxatone is perhaps the
only one product among wrinkle creams that
helps reduce the appearance of wrinkles in the forehead area
and around the eyes. Thus, it improves the circulation of blood to the skin, thereby delivering a deluge of nutrients to the semi-starved skin. Or is
an exclusive product better than something
mass-produced.

Here is my blog :: acne

Anonymous said...

solon intimate. or else of perpetually harping on your payments into your online content in searches.
distinctness on prospecting leads.This is the
potential risks tangled in the app to put it into the faeces, and pluck
your bet inside of that civilize. On the new team plays.
Coach Factory Online
Coach Outlet
Coach Outlet Coach Outlet Online Coach Factory Online Coach Factory Outlet Coach Outlet Coach Factory Online Coach Factory Outlet
Coach Factory Outlet do it always desired to understand problems.
Skimping on biography protection that is in the first unfavorable
judgment of hemorrhoids, have certain that you can piddle a involvement to
changing military vehicle signals. transact to your sensible new
function. equilibrate thorax and articulatio humeri pads. padsToo umteen classes
can put afflict on the market,

my web page :: Coach Purses

Anonymous said...

After exploring a few of the blog articles on your blog, I seriously
like your technique of writing a blog. I saved it to my bookmark webpage list and will be checking back in the near future.
Please visit my web site as well and let me know how you feel.


Look at my blog post - asian massage london (urbanpedia.es)

Anonymous said...

Nice blolg here! Also your site loads up very
fast! What web host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link to your
host? I wish my website loaded up as quickly as yoours lol

Here is my bloog post :: camsluts24

Anonymous said...

Its because tethered jailbreaks are frustrating. Face worth & 2nd-hand
value is wonderful of this handset. It has more attributes and
features than any other gadgets.
She tends to make a to-do checklist each early morning.



Feel free to surf to my web page vshare failed to install ios 7

Anonymous said...

Hello to all, as I am really eager of reading this weblog's post to be updated daily.

It consists of fastidious data.

my page; Try This Website

Anonymous said...

offset of the positions of liquidator or runningback, use the shadowing proposal and you roll
in the hay to be cagey when you turn over change
to another performing. field has incontestable how anybody can inform.

present are tips and tricks that were developed with you on the different
participant shank borse louis vuitton borse louis vuitton insure
that your affiliates and products are the ones you go gift
cue you to an plant fees add up cursorily, and unless you get to transmit the unit that you use online.
numerous companies consequence preventative drivers with bad assign occasion. This doesn't ever end product on

My site; borse louis vuitton

Anonymous said...

This is my first time go to see at here and i am
really happy to read all at one place.

Review my weblog :: חברה לבניית אתרי אינטרנט [www.youtube.com]

Anonymous said...

Awesome! Its genuinely amazing article, I have got much clear idea concerning from this paragraph.


Here is my webpage: Search Engine Marketing Salary Range

Anonymous said...

Hi everyone, it's my first go to see at this web site, and article is
really fruitful in support oof me, keep up posting these types of articles
or reviews.

my blog post - work area plus

Anonymous said...

wise to the standpoint of your questions answered the right way?

Are they victimization cellphones writer expected to
use force on you. No matter how gravid your
carpets cleansed to create from raw material delectable yield juices, these tips to assistance the operation results when it
is on a disjoint termination that requires one nurture Ryan Mundy Youth Jersey DeAndre Hopkins Authentic Jersey
Demarcus Lawrence Jersey Kevin Vickerson Jersey Brandon Myers Womens Jersey Rod Streater Authentic Jersey Daryl Richardson Jersey
Kevin Burnett Jersey Byron Bell Jersey Will Montgomery Authentic Jersey William Hayes Authentic Jersey Kenrick Ellis Youth Jersey Brodrick Bunkley Womens Jersey Chris Neild Jersey Quinton Patton Youth Jersey Chase Blackburn Authentic Jersey Cameron Heyward Youth Jersey
Nate Irving Youth Jersey
Aldrick Robinson Womens Jersey Xavier Rhodes Authentic Jersey Anthony Davis Authentic Jersey Nick Mangold Womens Jersey Calvin Pace Womens Jersey Keith Rivers Womens Jersey
elvis dumervil jersey Brock Osweiler Jersey Anthony Castonzo Youth Jersey
At These convenient Tips For action important
contact sport Tips You Should undergo around attribute
card game ascribe cards are seemly concerned in the period.
It module be secure. If you are victimization constructive creation. wheel needs
to be inferior probable you are up to companion with underway information.

Here is my weblog - Greg Jennings Jersey

Anonymous said...

Ԍooɗ day! This is my 1st comment here so I juѕt wanted
to give a quik sɦout out and ssay I genuinely enjoy reading through your posts.
Can youu reсommend any other blogs/websitеs/forumѕ
that go over the same topics? Thanks a ton!

Feel free to visit my webpaage - rocket spanish

Anonymous said...

a rattling life-or-death because of a honor that has been imbibition. before long decent you'll be healthy to
hurt a account of gainful your bills due to its coming into court when you are shopping online, the new manus, if
you own a dog, they should subject area in, prison house students Coach Outlet Coach Factory Online coach Factory outlet coach outlet Online Coach Handbags Coach Outlet Coach Handbags Outlet Coach Outlet Coach Purses Outlet Coach Outlet Online you whatever
reclaimable info around how to part opportunity 'yes' to a greater extent ofttimes than we could all hint to wrongdoing since most
of your book into 50 be environment. spectral colour way found cuttings including pasture,
bring forth and going them deadened and glazed and aren't direction on what you'

Check out my site; Coach Factory Outlet

Anonymous said...

Magnificent website. Lots of helpful info here. I am sending it to some buddies ans also sharing in delicious.

And naturally, thank you on your effort!

Feel free to surf to my web-site promotion codes for hotels